Cries of Inter students fall on deaf ears
Padmaja Shaw
Hans News Service
10 May 2019 4:02 AM
The death toll following the announcement of Intermediate results now has gone up to 24 with almost as many attempted suicides being reported from various parts of the State. The death toll following the announcement of Intermediate results now has gone up to 24 with almost as many attempted suicides being reported from various parts of the State. The government of Telangana, after initial bouts of denial, constituted a committee of three technical experts to probe into the incidents.
The experts said that both the Intermediate Board and its newly acquired technology partner Globarena were responsible for the errors in the results. However, it did not take the board for long to put out a press release claiming that the deaths were not the result of errors.
The evaluation of most of the students who had committed suicides had no major errors, it claimed. Part of the argument also says that the pass percentage is not unusual this year, but the politicisation is. For the government, it is a matter of riding out this storm to go back to business-as-usual. They have done this before. In 2016, the EAMCET paper leaked. A CID probe revealed that close to 90 people – students, parents, and printing presses in other States – were involved.
A dean of a corporate college Sri Chaitanya, and an admission agent of Narayana College were arrested after two years. It was reported that the culprits charged Rs 35 lakh per candidate for helping them get the question papers in advance. This is big money any way you look at it! The investigative agencies were having great difficulty filing charge sheets and prosecuting the culprits. We still do not know the fate of the probe and whether anyone will be prosecuted.
In the early years after the introduction of the common entrance exam for professional courses, students studied at regular Intermediate colleges where Physics, Chemistry, Botany and Zoology laboratories would be available. Weekly schedule of lab work was followed. Students were trained in accurately recording laboratory procedures and recognising various instruments and tools used in scientific experiments. Laboratory work formed a significant part of evaluation of students' comprehension of principles through practical examinations. Many of the old schools and Intermediate colleges still have laboratories and regular lab sessions. The common entrance in the early years required detailed answers, required drawing of diagrams. By early 1990s, fetishization of technical education began in tandem with the neo-liberal push towards privatisation of education. Suddenly, large numbers of private coaching shops began to mushroom across the State of Andhra Pradesh, which concentrated on imparting tricks and tips of cracking the entrance examinations. Soon 100-bit multiple-choice exams were introduced. This mode of evaluation eroded the need for comprehension of concepts and deemphasised the need for language skills. The reverse ripple of this trend distorted the earlier emphasis of school education on language skills and conceptual learning, so much so that now even in schools, much of the evaluation is done through the multiple-choice system.
By conducting centralised exams through multiple-choice questions, making them easily computable, the concern has been merely to produce quick results without real learning outcomes. We hear the debate year after year of engineering and other graduates being unemployable because of lack of language and analytical skills. In 2009, 25 percent weightage was introduced for Intermediate marks as premier engineering schools like BITS Pilani and IITs began to speak up about some of the high scoring students from the coaching shops lacking any exposure to laboratory procedures which an Intermediate student ought to have.
The affiliation application of the Board of Intermediate mentions one acre of land, building in urban areas and two acres of land, building in rural areas. If we close our eyes and remember all the junior colleges we see around us, it is evident that they should not be running those establishments from the second floor of a shopping complex. Most of the chains also do not have science labs. The way they conduct lab work through "mobile and shifting labs" for one week at a time should worry the regulators. In conventional junior colleges, the lab work follows after a topic is taught conceptually. Each week there is a regular schedule of lab sessions for all the science subjects. This is compressed into one convenient week for all topics in coaching centres. The mobile lab moves on to the next branch. At the end of it, how the practical exams are held and marks awarded is a scandal in itself. The government junior colleges are located in large land pieces with buildings, labs and playgrounds. Through deliberate neglect, by not recruiting teachers, by not allocating funds for keeping the existing facilities running, successive governments have undermined the junior college system. The State policies, and the loud publicity campaigns and physical enrolment drives taken up by the private junior colleges have shifted 82 percent of the student base from the State-run system towards the commercial system. To keep ahead of competition, the commercial establishments have not hesitated to indulge in malpractices such the EAMCET leak in 2016, though so far it is being portrayed as the work of rogue staff. Only not-for-profit registered societies are supposed to run educational institutions. Ironically, every debate on the junior college system calls the private colleges "corporate colleges". We have all accepted this rubric for them, therefore, tacitly accepting their right to put an unlawful price on our children's education. The collusion of parents in this short-cut to an elusive prosperous future is the unfortunate part of the story. The worst fallout of this hijack of science stream by corporate colleges is the lasting damage done to other streams. The All India Survey on Higher Education report (2016-17) says that 38 percent enrol in arts, humanities and social science course. Science courses are opted for by 16.7 percent. Engineering and technology by 14.7 percent and commerce by 14.1 percent at the undergraduate level. The prolonged freeze on recruitment in the State sector, cut back on funding for education ensured the closure/merger of junior colleges even as the private colleges entered the scene aggressively capturing the 'market.' Today, the crisis of the results is a consequence of this neglect of State sector. Junior colleges do not have experienced, qualified faulty in adequate numbers to evaluate the nearly ten lakh scripts. Large numbers of ad hoc, temporary teachers and teachers from private colleges are roped in for evaluation. A lot of information about the internal working of the system stands exposed. Parents and teachers have stepped out to protest. The State that regulates this crucial transition point of education must introspect too. Once the protests die down, it should not be business-as-usual.
https://www.thehansindia.com/hans/opinion/cries-of-inter-students-fall-on-deaf-ears--528065
Padmaja Shaw
Hans News Service
10 May 2019 4:02 AM
The death toll following the announcement of Intermediate results now has gone up to 24 with almost as many attempted suicides being reported from various parts of the State. The death toll following the announcement of Intermediate results now has gone up to 24 with almost as many attempted suicides being reported from various parts of the State. The government of Telangana, after initial bouts of denial, constituted a committee of three technical experts to probe into the incidents.
The experts said that both the Intermediate Board and its newly acquired technology partner Globarena were responsible for the errors in the results. However, it did not take the board for long to put out a press release claiming that the deaths were not the result of errors.
The evaluation of most of the students who had committed suicides had no major errors, it claimed. Part of the argument also says that the pass percentage is not unusual this year, but the politicisation is. For the government, it is a matter of riding out this storm to go back to business-as-usual. They have done this before. In 2016, the EAMCET paper leaked. A CID probe revealed that close to 90 people – students, parents, and printing presses in other States – were involved.
A dean of a corporate college Sri Chaitanya, and an admission agent of Narayana College were arrested after two years. It was reported that the culprits charged Rs 35 lakh per candidate for helping them get the question papers in advance. This is big money any way you look at it! The investigative agencies were having great difficulty filing charge sheets and prosecuting the culprits. We still do not know the fate of the probe and whether anyone will be prosecuted.
In the early years after the introduction of the common entrance exam for professional courses, students studied at regular Intermediate colleges where Physics, Chemistry, Botany and Zoology laboratories would be available. Weekly schedule of lab work was followed. Students were trained in accurately recording laboratory procedures and recognising various instruments and tools used in scientific experiments. Laboratory work formed a significant part of evaluation of students' comprehension of principles through practical examinations. Many of the old schools and Intermediate colleges still have laboratories and regular lab sessions. The common entrance in the early years required detailed answers, required drawing of diagrams. By early 1990s, fetishization of technical education began in tandem with the neo-liberal push towards privatisation of education. Suddenly, large numbers of private coaching shops began to mushroom across the State of Andhra Pradesh, which concentrated on imparting tricks and tips of cracking the entrance examinations. Soon 100-bit multiple-choice exams were introduced. This mode of evaluation eroded the need for comprehension of concepts and deemphasised the need for language skills. The reverse ripple of this trend distorted the earlier emphasis of school education on language skills and conceptual learning, so much so that now even in schools, much of the evaluation is done through the multiple-choice system.
By conducting centralised exams through multiple-choice questions, making them easily computable, the concern has been merely to produce quick results without real learning outcomes. We hear the debate year after year of engineering and other graduates being unemployable because of lack of language and analytical skills. In 2009, 25 percent weightage was introduced for Intermediate marks as premier engineering schools like BITS Pilani and IITs began to speak up about some of the high scoring students from the coaching shops lacking any exposure to laboratory procedures which an Intermediate student ought to have.
The affiliation application of the Board of Intermediate mentions one acre of land, building in urban areas and two acres of land, building in rural areas. If we close our eyes and remember all the junior colleges we see around us, it is evident that they should not be running those establishments from the second floor of a shopping complex. Most of the chains also do not have science labs. The way they conduct lab work through "mobile and shifting labs" for one week at a time should worry the regulators. In conventional junior colleges, the lab work follows after a topic is taught conceptually. Each week there is a regular schedule of lab sessions for all the science subjects. This is compressed into one convenient week for all topics in coaching centres. The mobile lab moves on to the next branch. At the end of it, how the practical exams are held and marks awarded is a scandal in itself. The government junior colleges are located in large land pieces with buildings, labs and playgrounds. Through deliberate neglect, by not recruiting teachers, by not allocating funds for keeping the existing facilities running, successive governments have undermined the junior college system. The State policies, and the loud publicity campaigns and physical enrolment drives taken up by the private junior colleges have shifted 82 percent of the student base from the State-run system towards the commercial system. To keep ahead of competition, the commercial establishments have not hesitated to indulge in malpractices such the EAMCET leak in 2016, though so far it is being portrayed as the work of rogue staff. Only not-for-profit registered societies are supposed to run educational institutions. Ironically, every debate on the junior college system calls the private colleges "corporate colleges". We have all accepted this rubric for them, therefore, tacitly accepting their right to put an unlawful price on our children's education. The collusion of parents in this short-cut to an elusive prosperous future is the unfortunate part of the story. The worst fallout of this hijack of science stream by corporate colleges is the lasting damage done to other streams. The All India Survey on Higher Education report (2016-17) says that 38 percent enrol in arts, humanities and social science course. Science courses are opted for by 16.7 percent. Engineering and technology by 14.7 percent and commerce by 14.1 percent at the undergraduate level. The prolonged freeze on recruitment in the State sector, cut back on funding for education ensured the closure/merger of junior colleges even as the private colleges entered the scene aggressively capturing the 'market.' Today, the crisis of the results is a consequence of this neglect of State sector. Junior colleges do not have experienced, qualified faulty in adequate numbers to evaluate the nearly ten lakh scripts. Large numbers of ad hoc, temporary teachers and teachers from private colleges are roped in for evaluation. A lot of information about the internal working of the system stands exposed. Parents and teachers have stepped out to protest. The State that regulates this crucial transition point of education must introspect too. Once the protests die down, it should not be business-as-usual.
https://www.thehansindia.com/hans/opinion/cries-of-inter-students-fall-on-deaf-ears--528065
Sudhakar Rao missed the deadline. He got back half an hour after the Telangana State Board of Intermediate Education released the results at around 5.30 pm. His daughter, Kaveti Lasya, 17, had failed one of her subjects, Mathematics 2B, and she felt devastated.
Sudhakar Rao consoled her, suggesting that she could take a supplementary exam to clear the subject without falling behind a year. Lasya agreed. She went to her room while her father got busy online looking up how to apply for the supplementary exam.
At around 6.30 pm, the family found Lasya hanging from the ceiling of her room.
Not long after, nearly 10 km away in Sri Nagar Colony, Dharma Ram, 17, jumped from the sixth-floor balcony of his building. Ram, who studied at Narayana College in Ameerpet, had also failed Mathematics 2B. “He was the only one in his class to have cleared the JEE test with 85%,” said his sister Mahitha Paturu. “He could not accept that he had failed in this exam.”
Of the 9.74 lakh students who appeared for Telangana’s intermediate exams for Classes XI and XII, 3.28 lakh failed this year. Fifty thousand candidates, Ram and Lasya among them, failed only mathamatics
The results triggered a spate of suicides. At least six students killed themselves the evening the results were announced. Within ten days, the toll climbed to 23.
The main reason the exam become a matter of life and death for so many students is that scores in the intermediate exams get a 25% weightage in the Engineering Agricultural and Medical Common Entrance Test, or EAMCET, students, parents and education experts told Scroll.in. This is the test that determines admission to medical, agricultural and engineering colleges in Telangana.
In addition, tests like EAMCET and JEE, the national exam for admission to IITs and engineering colleges, have come to be the marker of academic achievement.
“The idea that we have to aspire only for engineering or medicine is sown into our minds right from high school,” said a cousin of Lasya’s who asked not to be identified. “Any other course is looked down upon. We are basically told that these are the only two options.”
This obsession with medicine and engineering has been fueled, and exploited, by profit-driven private colleges. Their big draw is that they offer to prepare students for the intermediate exams and entrance tests simultaneously.
“There are at least 2,203 private intermediate colleges in the state and only 404 government colleges,” said Madhusudhan Reddy, president of the Government Junior College Lecturers’ Association.
Hard-driving atmosphere
Institutions run by the Sri Chaitanya and the Narayana groups are among the most sought-after. The Sri Chaitanya group’s reputation for preparing students for entrance exams persuaded Sudhakar Rao to admit his daughter to the Sri Chaitanya College in Secunderabad to study Mathematics, Physics and Chemistry, paying Rs 1.40 lakh a year in fees. Aside from teaching her the required intermediate courses, the college also prepared Lasya to take EAMCET and the JEE.
“We did not want to burden her by sending her to tuition classes,” said Sudhakar Rao. “So we chose a semi-residential college that offered regular classes and training for entrance exams under one roof.”
For two years, Lasya had to keep a 12-hour schedule. She took practice exams every Saturday and Monday.
“They are given multiple choice questions to answer like in entrance exams for IITs or EAMCET,” said Sudhakar Rao. “Results are sent via SMS to each student’s parents and displayed on the college’s noticeboards. They teach the regular courses only at the fag end of the academic year.”
In the intermediate exams conducted by the state board, though, students are required to write detailed answers. Since there is little time to prepare for this, the colleges encourage rote learning. But this strategy does not work for Mathematics, Lasya’s cousin said.
“Every student who enters intermediate college has to go through this grind,” she added. “Those two years are the worst of our lives.”
Rising suicides